Yes, I agree. Also, I hate the way they treat guns. You are on an island where you need food to eat, and there are wild animals, but OHHHHH, GUNS ARE BAD! LOCK IT UP! :eusa_wall
This aspect really KILLS ME, because it is so idiotic! If I was on that island, I would punch the doctor in the face, and say, "Give me that gun you moron!", and I would shoot the first wild animal I saw, instead of trying to trap it or chasing it with a pointy stick! _@_
The reason the guns were locked up was to keep the two volatile characters from having them. You remember? Thos guys that were fighting nearly to the death? The ones that were involved with the torture?
Nahhh You're right. Just throw the guns out to the least trustworthy characters and trust their judgement to not use it one themselves.