What's new
Guest viewing is limited

PC Magazine - A Waste of Paper

Diesel

Peak Forum Legend
PF Member
Messages
6,612
Highlights
0
Reaction score
1
Points
0
Peak Coin
0.000000¢
DB Transfer
0.000000¢
I made the mistake of buying the new issue of PC Magazine, despite the fact that I know that they have no idea as to what they are talking about.

I was interested in the cover story they had on new 3D cards. However, when I got to the benchmarks, I was astounded that these guys haven't figured out just how stupid they are! Not only are they not, in the slightest, technically knowledgable, but apparently, they have no journalistic or editorial skills either.

Review the benchmark results from the article.

Most glaring item of stupidity:
How the Elsa Gladiac 32MB (based on GF2 GTS) is 40% faster on the Athlon than on the P3, while the Elsa Gladiac Ultra 64MB (based on GF2 Ultra) is not only 40% slower on the Athlon than on the P3, but somehow clocked in slower than the Gladiac on the Athlon.
As we all know, the Ultra is basically identical to the the GTS, only with faster memory and a faster core.

So, pray tell, how does the same card, only faster, come out slower?

Furthermore, they go on to show that they're even dumber by giving their Editor's Choice to a GTS Pro card, while they clearly show several GTS Ultra cards to benchmark faster at not much of a price premium.

I remember now why I leave my magazines in the bathroom. Because when I find one like this, the only logical and useful thing to do is to wipe my **** with it and flush it down the toilet.

----------------------------
spidergoolash: "heh, a cup of diesel dan - mwahhha"
me: "heh, a cup of me is like a cup of heaven!"
 
yeah i think i got that one too.. i get the occasional PC Magazine when i have a plane ride and need something to read..

I usually find the articles on pda's/printers/web cams.. some what usefull since i don't keep up on those things at all..

there was also a Who's E-shopping article i found interesting..

granted.. they arent the benchmarking wizz for video cards.. but they do enough to satisfy their target group.. gaming hardware enthusiasts do not fall under that catagory
 
PDA's I could see.
However, PC Mag has always shown an overwhelmingly strong HP bias in the printer arena.
Despite Epson and Lexmark offering higher resolutions and more features at lower cost, including Price per page, they continue to rate HP printers higher across the board.

I would take any of their commentary (because I certainly can't call it advice or recommendations) with a grain of salt, and consider the source.


----------------------------
spidergoolash: "heh, a cup of diesel dan - mwahhha"
me: "heh, a cup of me is like a cup of heaven!"
 
Back
Top