Teenage gamer may go to prison for 8 years for violent joke on League of Legends

Jordioa18

Established Talker
PF Member
A Texas teenager who has been in jail since March faces an eight-year prison sentence because of a threatening joke he made while playing an online video game.

In February, Justin Carter was playing ?League of Legends? ? an online, multiplayer fantasy game ? when another player wrote a comment calling him insane. Carter?s response, which he now deeply regrets, was intended as joke.

?He replied ?Oh yeah, I?m real messed up in the head, I?m going to go shoot up a school full of kids and eat their still, beating hearts,? and the next two lines were lol and jk,? said Jack Carter, Justin?s father, in a statement to a local news channel.

The statements ?lol? and ?jk? ? meaning ?laughing out loud? and ?just kidding? ? indicate that Justin?s statement was entirely sarcastic, said his father.

But a Canadian woman who saw the post looked up Carter?s Austin address, determined that it was near an elementary school, and called the police. Carter was arrested one month later, and has been in jail ever since. He recently celebrated his 19th birthday behind bars.

Authorities charged him with making a terrorist threat. If convicted, he will face eight years in prison.

?These people are serious. They really want my son to go away to jail for a sarcastic comment that he made,? said the elder Carter.

Authorities noted that recent school shootings like the one in Newtown, Connecticut have caused them to evaluate all potential threats seriously. Newtown was still fresh in their minds at the time of Carter?s arrest.

?In light of recent situations, statements such as the one Justin made are taken seriously,? said an Austin police detective in a statement.

"Carter?s father said his son didn?t follow the news at all.

?Justin was the kind of kid who didn?t read the newspaper,? said Jack Carter. ?He didn?t watch television. He wasn?t aware of current events. These kids, they don?t realize what they?re doing. They don?t understand the implications. They don?t understand.?

Carter?s parents have launched a change.org petition to convince Texas Attorney General Greg Abbot to release their son.

?Release Justin Carter from jail,? the petition reads. ?Too many teenagers are being arrested, jailed and having their lives forever altered because of anti-terrorism laws and investigations that impede their 1st Amendment right to freedom of speech.?

A hearing to review Carter?s case is scheduled for July 1."



Original article: http://dailycaller.com/2013/06/27/t...ideo-game-is-jailed-for-months/#ixzz2XhCg0V75

This blows my mind, he godnondeju used sarcasm, HE EVEN POINTED IT OUT! It just blows my mind that he gets more punishment than someone doing a normal crime (Stealing and breaking in are examples). Looks like sarcasm is becoming illegal, and it even doesn't make sense! Here's a video about someone discussing about this and seemingly more angry than I am.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nc_4XpbK72o

What is your opinion on this?
 
Lmao what. Okay so his comment was really wrong and probably pushes the sickipedia limits but seriously, although I'd ban him from the website for that...he doesn't deserve to go to prison. I'm sorry, everyone needs to calm down.
 
Woah people take stuff too seriously. This is crazy ridiculous. I've said so much worse stuff to my friends in a joking manner.
 
Well, I reckon America is like that. It has happened that kids got shot randomly in schools, so they are pretty sensitive to threats of the sort, and wary of it happening again. Specially in Texas.
Buttttttttt at the same time this is weird. A canadian finding out the address of an american? Hm.
 
I love how the American authorities and government would punish a barely adult boy for a stupid comment he made rather than institute some firearm restrictions and other policies to help the mentally insane so that these sorts of school shooting crimes happen less frequently or not at all. There is so much wrong with this.
 
The sentence is really harsh, but I agree with him being arrested. Even if he wrote "lol jk", who's to say if he were serious or not? I think it's perfectly fine to arrest him and then do the necessary checks to see if he was joking.

Just give him a hefty fine.
 
Imagine whacking someone with a baseball bat or something and saying 'lol jk' after to make it all okay.
If he really does go through those 8 years in prison, then his life is ruined. I understand he was being sarcastic, especially while doing it so publicly, but it was still wrong to say - so he should have got something like a warning. Or even as Kirk said, about arresting him and doing the necessary checks.

It's cool, they've still got all those murderers out there while they're wasting their time, space and money on a young teen for being sarcastic.
 
I was about to post the exactly same thing...

I play LOL. I am going to prison O.o
 
I was about to post the exactly same thing...

I play LOL. I am going to prison O.o

There's getting angry at people and threatening to kill them or others. This kid is obviously too immature or stupid not to understand the potential consequences of his actions.
 
The thing that should really be shocking people isn't the sentence itself, but this.

But a Canadian woman who saw the post looked up Carter?s Austin address, determined that it was near an elementary school, and called the police.

Just from that she was able to find where he lived, as well as his details.
 
Just from that she was able to find where he lived, as well as his details.

The email address associated with his account probably shows up on Google somewhere and he's put his address on a profile or something. She can't have done anything illegal to obtain the information otherwise she would have been arrested (probably?).
 
Are you kidding me? I would like the government to just sit on xbox live for a few minutes playing CoD. This is why I hate my country, I should have all my amendments protected like promises and not having to watch what I say. This isn't Russia.
 
The thing that should really be shocking people isn't the sentence itself, but this.



Just from that she was able to find where he lived, as well as his details.

It's not very difficult which is pretty scary. Some kid annoyed us on Minecraft by cheating and from his online name I managed to find his home address in about 20 minutes (we didn't actually do anything though).
 
No WAY should this child have been arrested! So now the government thinks they can dictate and police our THOUGHTS???!!!?! Justin didn't act on his (admittedly stupid) joke, he made a comment. This isn't some drop-out junkie loser kid wandering around pissing his life away! He's just a kid, playing a game and acting like a teenager. To punish him for this non-issue will have some very bad results for his future. How can anyone believe this kid did something worthy of a record?? It's absurd, it's ridiculous. Things like this need to be looked at case-by-case and handled accordingly. What a waste of an already over-burdened judicial system!
It's also another example of how the government is slowly but surely chipping away at our rights and liberties. If we keep allowing things like this to go unanswered, we'll wake up one day and find ourselves living in a communist society without any basic human rights.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
The Canadian woman who reported the whole thing should have been arrested instead, for wasting police time. Honestly.
 
The sentence is really harsh, but I agree with him being arrested. Even if he wrote "lol jk", who's to say if he were serious or not? I think it's perfectly fine to arrest him and then do the necessary checks to see if he was joking.

Just give him a hefty fine.

Welcome to america.

This ^ tbh and ban him from the site nothing else more needs to be done, but with the recent shootings that has been going on I don't blame the police for arresting him they're just doing there job.
 
Back
Top