Directly from SBI President on Karaoke Downloads
Chartbusterette said:
The recording would make it easier to edit. If you could make those edits on the fly, the same violations would still occur. But of course, you know that already, you are merely trying to throw a red herring into the mix because you have no answer, do you?
If I make those edits on the playback, there' nothing you can do about it and none of your rights regarding any IP property have been violated, period. If you think otherwise, then where are all the lawsuits against regular DJ's for using cuepoints, beat-on-beat mixing, scratching or any other method to "alter the original?"
You're simply blowing as much smoke as you possibly can to make it appear as though you have some of control over the USE of your product.
Nice try.
Chartbusterette said:
No you don't. "All Rights Reserved." It's not fair use, it's not parody, and it's not educational. If you are performing the same type of edits, then you are in violation as well. Are you?
How patently ridiculous. Show me the law where it's a violation.... I'll wait.... In the meantime, show me the "list of all rights reserved" in the copyright law that pertains to any alteration in THE PERFORMANCE.
Again, nice try. No cigar.
Chartbusterette said:
You don't know what our insurance policies and riders are. You are just blowing smoke for the sake of trying to appear like you know more than you do. Furthermore, that's another straw dog, as you are alluding to us being a defendant, not a plaintiff.
Yeah, right....
How's this for a reminder :
Case 3:07-cv-00370
Filed 04-06-2007
Indiana Insurance Co.
vs
Tennessee Production Center Inc.,
Norbert Stovall and Debi Stovall
Chartbusterette said:
It certainly does speak volumes... about copyright law. We can't touch the toolmakers, as long as the tools have valid uninfringing uses, any more than we could sue the makers of locksmith tools if a burglar uses them to break into our house.
Just as you can't touch a KJ who blanks out the video on playback whenever they see fit to do so.
Chartbusterette said:
Why, Mr. Staley, as I've already said multiple times, simply send me your real name and address and I'd be happy to send you all of that paperwork, at our own expense.
Nice try (again). You've NEVER offered to produce your claimed copyright registrations, as a matter of fact, you been nothing but evasive about proving their existence. Your only offer to show anything was attached to driving to your office in TN to see them.
So now show me the "multiple times" you are now claiming you've offered anything different.... I'll wait.
Chartbusterette said:
I invite you to test that theory. Videotape such a performance by yourself and send it to me.
Unless you lack the courage of your own convictions.
Stinky bait.... Besides, I wouldn't know who to address it to - it appears as though 3 people write under your name....